The last time you filled your car’s tank with regular gasoline, the average reference price in the metropolitan area was Q32.07 per gallon, according to the official report of October 26. At the beginning of the month, before the tax exemption was fully reflected, it cost more. Since October 1, a law has been in force that temporarily eliminated two fuel taxes. Your receipt shows how much was cut per gallon. You can verify it every time you fill up.
But we came close to taking another path. Congress had approved a law that set maximum prices of Q39 per gallon for regular gasoline and diesel, and Q41 for premium. If the market price exceeded those limits, you would pay the maximum and the State would cover the difference. Where would the money come from? From the same taxpayers. Congress had earmarked Q2,500 million to finance that subsidy, more than half of what the State collected throughout 2025 from the fuel distribution tax.
On September 30, the president vetoed that law and signed another that followed a different path: temporarily eliminating the VAT and the fuel distribution tax until December 31, without imposing any price. It also required gas stations to show on every receipt how much had been cut per gallon. Instead of subsidizing consumption with taxpayers’ money, the State gave up collecting two taxes. Consumers could verify the reduction on their own receipts.
Behind these two decisions lies a much more important question: who should decide the price of what is yours? You, who work, invest, and risk your money, or an official who decides for you? Guatemala has just cut taxes without fixing prices. Meanwhile, Berlin and New York are debating or applying measures that allow authorities to intervene in rents and, in Berlin’s case, even in the ownership of housing. The discussion seems distant, until we imagine those same decisions being made about our own homes.
On September 20, Berlin held regional elections. Turnout reached 74%, and Die Linke, the left-wing party, doubled its vote compared to 2023: it went from 12% to 26% and became the leading force in the Berlin Parliament, with 45 of 153 seats. Its election platform contains a proposal of enormous significance for private property: transferring to the public sector hundreds of thousands of homes belonging to private companies.
Die Linke’s platform runs 336 pages, but its conception of housing appears in the very first ones: “Housing is not a commodity like any other. Housing is a right.” From that premise, the party proposes that the State intervene directly in rents and in the ownership of large real estate companies. The scope of that intervention is better understood by examining the concrete measures it proposes.
The proposed measures begin with the nearly 400,000 homes owned by the State of Berlin: freezing their rents for one year and, afterward, allowing increases of at most 1% per year. The platform also provides that tenants could request reductions when their rents exceed the local average by more than 20%. A new office would monitor compliance with the rules and penalize violations. Prices would thus be subject to limits set by the authority.
There is an additional provision: when one of those homes becomes vacant, the next contract must be set 10% below the area’s average rent. Even if money has been invested in improving it, the price of the new contract must respect that limit. The authority would thus determine how much can be charged for a home that returns to the rental market.
But the most far-reaching proposal directly affects private property. Die Linke’s platform proposes socializing some 220,000 homes belonging to large real estate companies. The German Constitution has contained, since 1949, a legal mechanism for socializing certain assets: Vergesellschaftung. The transfer would require a law and compensation under the constitutional framework; the amount and concrete conditions are legal and political questions yet to be defined. We are talking about 220,000 homes, more than half of those the Berlin State already owns. Their owners could be forced to transfer them even if they did not want to sell.
These measures have not yet been applied. Die Linke has been negotiating since October 8 to form a government with the Greens and the Social Democrats, while the outgoing mayor remains in office. For now they are campaign proposals, whose future will depend on political agreements; the negotiations have discussed scopes different from those in the platform. But there is another city where authorities have already intervened directly in the rents of private housing: New York.
On June 25 of this year, in New York, nine members of a regulatory board met in a Manhattan museum to decide on the allowed increases for about one million rent-stabilized apartments. By seven votes to one, they approved a 0% increase for certain one- and two-year leases beginning between October 2026 and September 2027. Roughly a quarter of the city’s residents live in those homes. The board members do not personally bear the costs of repairs, taxes, or maintenance of the buildings whose rents they regulate.
For the first time, the board extended the freeze on allowed increases to two-year leases as well. Zohran Mamdani had made “freeze the rent” one of his main campaign promises. During his first half-year as mayor, that proposal coincided with a decision by the regulatory body, whose members are appointed by the mayor.
The political organization Mamdani belongs to, the Democratic Socialists of America, maintains in its platform that housing is a human right and proposes universal rent control. Mamdani’s own campaign platform does not use that formulation, but it does include the proposal to freeze rents. Thus a political conception of access to housing is translated into concrete measures that limit the prices landlords may charge.
In November 2025 we wrote in this column about the consequences Mamdani’s proposals could have. Today he is mayor of New York, and the rent freeze he promoted is already part of the city’s regulatory decisions.
New York landlords warn that freezing rents while costs rise can reduce the resources available to maintain and repair buildings. According to the regulatory board’s own measurement, operating costs rose 5.3% in one year. For the tenant, the freeze means immediate relief; for the landlord, it means facing growing expenses without being able to adjust the rent on the affected leases. The question is what will happen to the maintenance of those homes if that gap persists for several years.
What would happen if Guatemala adopted those same measures? If you are a property owner, would you keep building homes to rent out if an official could limit how much you charge? And if you are a tenant, what would happen when you needed to find another apartment and there were fewer and fewer homes available?
For someone who rents, freezing the price seems like good news: they will pay the same next year. But what will happen when their children look for a place to live? If building apartments to rent stops being profitable, fewer investors will be willing to finance them. And if demand grows while construction slows, finding housing will become harder and harder. Urban-planning and administrative restrictions have helped limit supply in markets like California and Spain, although they are not the only cause of rising prices. Today’s relief can become tomorrow’s scarcity. And no decree can put up for rent the apartments that were never built.
In Guatemala we have just experienced a different decision. The State temporarily eliminated two taxes, without imposing a maximum price or financing a subsidy through budget transfers. The tax cut appears on each consumer’s receipt. The price continued to be determined by the market, while the State reduced the tax burden on each gallon. But that exemption ends on December 31: if the law is not amended, both taxes will be collected again starting January 1, 2027. The tax reduction has an expiration date.
There is a fact we must acknowledge: diesel registered an average reference price of Q42.69 per gallon in the metropolitan area on October 26, more than the Q39 the consumer would have paid under the subsidy scheme approved by Congress. For those who use diesel, the difference matters. But it also matters who would have financed that Q3.69-per-gallon difference had the subsidy been in force under the same conditions. It would have come from taxpayers, charged against a Q2,500 million allocation. The exemption, by contrast, reduces tax revenue. They are two different mechanisms, both with fiscal costs and different effects on consumers and public finances.
Guatemala had two paths on the table. One would have committed up to Q2,500 million of the budget to sustaining maximum prices. The other temporarily cut two taxes and let prices continue to be determined by the market. Berlin and New York show another dimension of the debate: how much power authorities should have over prices and property. Incentives matter: when investing in housing is attractive, supply can grow and prices can moderate. San Francisco, Oakland, and Barcelona already face serious problems of housing access, to which restrictions on building have contributed. Do we want our children to face that same scarcity twenty years from now? Or do we want a Guatemala where investing in building more housing is good business and, thanks to a growing supply, more and more families have the chance to afford it?
Ramiro Bolaños, PhD. / President of the Centro de Pensamiento y Acción Factoría Libertatis
References
- California Department of Housing and Community Development, housing planning and regulatory constraints documents; City of Oakland, Housing Element.
- Congreso de la República de Guatemala, Decreto 21-2026, approved September 9, 2026 and vetoed September 30, 2026.
- Congreso de la República de Guatemala, Decreto 22-2026, Ley de Exención Tributaria Temporal de Emergencia al Consumidor de Combustibles, published in the Diario de Centro América on September 30, 2026; in force from October 1 to December 31, 2026.
- Democratic Socialists of America, DSA Political Platform, 2021 convention, section “Housing For All.”
- Die Linke Berlin, Wahlprogramm zur Abgeordnetenhauswahl 2026, Berlin, 2026.
- Landeswahlleiter für Berlin and Amt für Statistik Berlin-Brandenburg, Wahl zum 20. Abgeordnetenhaus von Berlin am 20. September 2026: Amtliches Endergebnis, October 12, 2026.
- Ministerio de Energía y Minas, fuel reference prices at self-service stations, Guatemala metropolitan area, October 26, 2026.
- New York City Rent Guidelines Board, vote on lease renewal adjustments 2026-2027, June 25, 2026.
- Office of the Mayor of New York City, press release on municipal grocery store program sites, April 2026.
- Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD), economic and housing surveys on Spain, 2025–2026.
- Superintendencia de Administración Tributaria and Ministerio de Finanzas Públicas, revenue by tax, fiscal year 2025.